You’re about to start a recipe and realize you don’t have one of the key ingredients—buttermilk! Don’t you worry, we’ve got the solution. Keep reading for all of our buttermilk substitutes!
Don’t have buttermilk? make it!
There are a lot of recipes that call for buttermilk. Biscuits, buttermilk pancakes, buttermilk syrup…
Sometimes I want to make these recipes but I don’t have any buttermilk in my fridge. That’s where these simple buttermilk substitute recipes come in and save the day! So instead of having to run to the store, just use one of these subs instead.
What is the difference between milk and buttermilk: First off, buttermilk is NOT milk that has gone bad. If you have sour smelling milk, toss it out. Buttermilk is milk combined with lactic acid. The acid reacts to the baking ingredients and produces a tangy taste along with a lighter fluffy texture.
What is a Substitute for Buttermilk?
There are a few substitutes for buttermilk that you can use, or you can even make your own buttermilk. Both are great options!
Always use a 1:1 ratio substitute. so if the recipe calls for ½ c buttermilk, then use ½ c milk substitute.
Need 2 cups buttermilk? Use 2 cups of the substitute.
You get the idea. 😉
How to Make Buttermilk
There are many ways to make buttermilk. Our go-to recipe usually is with milk and lemon juice. But today, we are not only sharing this recipe, but as well as several others you can use as well.
If you need to make 1 cup of buttermilk substitute you’ll need:
- 1 cup of milk
- Add 1 tbsp of white vinegar OR lemon juice OR cream of tartar. Do not add all three. Only choose one to mix with the milk (we typically use lemon juice)
- Stir and let it sit for 5 minutes
It’s that easy. After it has set for 5 minutes, you’re ready to use it in any recipe that calls for buttermilk.
Buttermilk Substitute Yogurt
Another substitute can be made with yogurt. Here is what you’ll need:
- ¾ cup plain yogurt
- ¼ cup milk
- Mix and sit for 5 minutes
Note: always allow the mixture to rest for 5 minutes so allow it so combine and curdle a bit.
Sour Cream + Kefir Substitute
Another one? Whisk together sour cream and milk (or even water).
- 2/3 cup sour cream
- ⅓ cup milk
- Mix and sit for 5 minutes
This hack is particular good in coffee cakes and pancakes.
KEFIR: No tinkering needed for this one: substitute equal parts kefir for buttermilk in any recipe—just make sure it’s unsweetened, unflavored kefir.
Store: Store buttermilk in an airtight container like a mason jar in the fridge for 1-2 weeks.
Can you freeze buttermilk substitute? You can freeze buttermilk and the buttermilk substitute. Hopefully, between the two you’ll always have some on hand. I suggest using an ice cube tray. Measure 1 tbsp of buttermilk for each slot in the tray. Freeze. Once frozen, transfer the cubes to a freezer Ziploc. Label and keep frozen for up to 3 months.
Recipes using Buttermilk:
Buttermilk Substitute Recipe
- 1 cup milk
- 1 tbsp lemon juice
- Stir ingredients together until combined.
- Let sit for 5 minutes before using in a recipe.
I have never made my own & hate when a recipe calls for buttermilk, but I am out. This will come in so handy!! Thanks!
this is wonderful because recipes never usually call for that much buttermilk so i end up wasting my store-brought ones. i will just make my own now!
I have done this with vinegar before. Such a great hack when you are in a pinch. 🙂
I have never thought to make my own buttermilk. Thanks for the idea. It will save me a trip to the store one of these days for sure.
I didn’t know you could use lemon juice, i always just use vinegar. You would think i would keep regular buttermilk on hand as often as I use it!
I love the convienence of using Regular items when you Dont have buttermilk in your fridge. There really is no difference. So nice to know!
Need buttermilk, this helps to know how to make my own!! Have plain Yogurt, did not know what to do with it, now I know one thing!! Have anymore, how to use plain yogurt?? Would love to here them!!
Oh I’m glad this was helpful! Yes, a few ideas are to fluff up waffles, use it in a warm soup (similar to a sour cream substitute), use it as a veggie dip (add some other spices or a packet of dry onion soup mix), make frozen yogurt pops or drops, use it in smoothies, etc. There are lots of ideas on the internet too!
Does this recipe work ok with regular milk?
Yep! That’s typically what I use…. milk and lemon juice. But there are a few options listed in the post to make your own buttermilk.
I was somehow never able to make the lemon juice hack work until I started getting the True Lemon brand freeze-dried juice powder! (You can get this online and in some stores, and they have other citrus flavors too that are very nice for putting in water or using in recipes. Want Orange-Cranberry scones but you’re out of OJ, or want a more pronounced orange flavor? It’s your answer!) And I’ve never had a better homemade lemonaid in my life than with this stuff and SO quick!!
I think the bottled liquid lemon juice has added ingredients that make it shelf stable, makes it taste awful and seems to interfere with the above process somehow. HOWEVER, adding just a little water to some of the powdered True Lemon (that tastes SO much better than the bottled stuff anyhow) before adding it to the milk makes this recipe PERFECT without adding too much liquid that it just thickens right up!!
Another fairly important note is that 1% and non-fat milk have never worked for me, no matter how hard I tried. And whole milk *always* works better than 2% – think about the name “butter-milk”.. the higher the butterfat content, the better it works. I haven’t ever tried to make buttermilk with heavy cream because I think it would be way too think and heavy cream is expensive to throw out if it fails, so I’ve never tried it. I have however used 1/2 and 1/2 and it’s amazingly thick and works awesome for something like a homemade ranch for people who are used to HV brand shelf-stable ranch! That stuff is so think with thickeners, something people used to store-bought ranch dressing are used to, texture-wise. It’s the only way I got my grandkids to eat the homemade type, they’re used to the thick store bought and wouldn’t touch the homemade because it was “too watery.”
Once I made it with 1/2 and 1/2, they just asked about the tangy taste and I had a pouch of the powdered HV brand buttermilk-style in the panty (that had been sitting there forever because hubby bought it thinking he was helping me out,) and I showed them it said “buttermilk” on it and they just shrugged and ate it happily. They recognized the branded label. When they’re older I’ll teach them to make the homemade version and explain I switched “years ago” and they never noticed, and they’ll be fine. Just gotta work with their limited understanding and social programming.
Now if I could just get that to work with my brand-obsessed S-I-L and I’d be golden… LOL
Thanks for sharing all of those tips!!