How to Pick A Good Watermelon

These super simple tips and tricks on how to pick out a good watermelon will give you a juicy and sweet melon every time!

Be sure to follow these steps on how to pick a good watermelon so it will be juicy every time. Serve up those sweet slices with a pile of Dr. Pepper Ribs and Corn on the Cob for a perfect summer BBQ!

A perfectly picked slice of ripe watermelon.

Who Doesn’t Love Watermelon?!

In the summertime, I’m especially obsessed with this sweet and refreshing fruit, and I often think about how wonderful life would be if I had it in my fridge all year long!

Over the years, I’ve learned a few tips and trips for picking out the juiciest watermelon and I wanted to make sure you knew what they were so you could use them too.

I know people often say that buying a sweet watermelon is hit or miss, but it doesn’t have to be if you look for a few things when you’re picking out your melon. Once you have it chosen, I also have tips for cutting watermelon.

Delicious, red, and juicy!! That’s how a perfect watermelon should be, and if you follow these tips on how to pick a good watermelon it should help you snag a sweet melon. 😉

A whole watermelon picked with simple tips and tricks.

How to Pick a Watermelon

How to tell if a watermelon is ripe? When testing the ripeness of a watermelon keep these tips in mind:

  • Look for the large yellow spot (field spot) on the underside of the watermelon. This is where the watermelon was laying in the field. Make sure it’s a decent size and has a nice creamy yellow spot.
  • Give it a good thump. Give it a tap or knock, you want to make sure it has a hollow deep sound.
  • Dull outside. Make sure the outside of the watermelon looks dull and not shiny. A shiny watermelon means it’s not ripe. The green stripes should be a deep dark green while the white strips should be a light yellow/cream.
  • Lift it up. Make sure it’s heavy for its size, which means it has a ton of water in it (what you want!!)
  • Nice oval shape. A uniform shape watermelon shows that it got the perfect amount of sunshine and water.
  • Bee stings and white scars (sugar spots). Look for these little guys. These little marks show that it’s sweet enough that even the bees were trying to get to the inside. The stings look like brown lines or dots on the melon.
  • Sweet aroma. The best watermelons have a sweet aroma. Scratch a bit off the green skin. You should be able to smell a sweet aroma through the rind of the melon.
  • Tendril. Most watermelons at the grocery store will not have a tendril, but if you are choosing one from a farmers market or are lucky enough to have one growing in your garden, locate the curly tendril, where the melon is/was connected to the vine. The tendril should be dried out. If it still has a green stem, then the melon is not ripe.
  • Avoid watermelons that are shiny, and have soft spots, bruises, dents, or irregular bumps.
Using the yellow spot and marks to pick a perfect watermelon.

Serving Tips

Not sure about you guys, but ripe watermelon is a must for the Fourth of July, so I’m hoping these tips will help you when picking a watermelon for Independence Day :).

Another thing we like to do for the Fourth and during the summer is making Watermelon Juice – SOOO good! Or whip up a big fresh glass of Frozen Strawberry Lemonade.

Cubed chunks of watermelon in a white bowl.

Storing Tips

An uncut watermelon. Keep the uncut melon at room temperature for 1-2 weeks, or in the fridge for 7-10 days. 

For a cut watermelon. If you only sliced a portion of the melon, then tightly wrap the uncut portion with plastic wrap and store it in the fridge for 4-5 days. Cut watermelon cubes can be stored in an airtight container in the fridge for 2-3 days. Drain excess liquid before serving.

Freeze watermelon chunks. Store cut watermelon in the freezer to use in smoothies, sorbet, or gazpacho.

  • Remove the seeds from the chunks and flash-freeze them.
  • Line a pan with parchment paper and arrange the cut melon evenly over the pan.
  • Freeze until solid, then transfer to a freezer-safe container. It can keep for 3-6 months.
A ripe and juicy slice of perfectly picked watermelon.

Recipe FAQ

How can I tell if a watermelon is sweet?

Look for melons with bee stings that look like brown lines or dots on the melon. These little marks show that it’s sweet enough that even the bees were trying to get to the inside.

How big of a watermelon should I buy?

When cut into ¾ inch wedges, a medium 20-pound watermelon can produce 66 pieces. Divide 66 by the number of pieces you think your guests will eat. I find people eat an average of 3 slices, so 22 guests.

How do I keep watermelon cool outside?

Whether whole or cut, keep the watermelon in a cooler with ice. When it’s time to serve it, place some ice in a bowl and then nestle the bowl of cut watermelon into the ice.

For More Tips, Check Out:

How to Pick Out a Good Watermelon

5 from 3 votes
These super simple tips and tricks on how to pick out a good watermelon will give you a juicy and sweet melon every time!
Course Side Dish
Cook Time 2 minutes
Total Time 2 minutes
Servings 1 watermelon
Author Lil’ Luna

Ingredients

  • 1 watermelon

Instructions
 

  • Look for the large yellow spot on the underside of the watermelon. This is where the watermelon was laying in the field. Make sure it's a decent size and has a nice yellow patch.
  • Give it a good thump. Give it a tap or knock, you want to make sure it has a hollow sound.
  • Dull outside. You want to make sure the outside of the watermelon looks dull and not shiny. A shiny watermelon means it's not ripe.
  • Lift it up. You want to make sure it's heavy for it's size, which means it has a ton of water in it (what you want!!)
  • Nice oval shape. A uniform-shaped watermelon shows that it got the perfect amount of sunshine and water.
  • Bee stings and white scars. Look for these little guys. These little marks show that it's sweet enough that even the bees were trying to get to the inside. The stings look like brown lines or dots on the melon.
  • Sweet aroma. Scratch a bit off the green skin. You should be able to smell a sweet aroma through the rind of the melon.
  • Tendril. Most watermelons at the grocery store will not have a tendril, but if you are choosing one from a farmers market or are lucky enough to have one growing in your garden locate the curly tendril, where the melon is/was connected to the vine. The tendril should be dried out. If it still has a green stem, then the melon is not ripe.

Like this recipe?

Pin it now to remember it later! Share it with your Facebook friends (you know they’ll love it). Or tweet it to the world. Maybe even email it to your favorite cousin!

Related Posts

Gnat Trap

This Gnat Trap (or Fruit Fly Trap) literally takes 2 minutes to put together and works AWESOME! Say goodbye to fruit flies! This gnat trap is a great DIY solution…

4 minutes minutes

How to Cut a Watermelon

Is there anything better than a ripe juicy watermelon? Learn How to Cut a Watermelon into cubes, sticks, and triangles with our top tips! Grab that perfect watermelon and cut…

5 minutes minutes

5 from 22 votes

How to Ripen Bananas

Learn how to ripen bananas quickly using a brown paper bag, the oven, or the microwave – for all of your favorite banana recipes! Use these tips on how to…

20 minutes minutes

How to Boil Eggs

Learn how to boil eggs to be perfect and it’s to peel. It’s quick, simple, and NO FAIL – we’ve tested so many methods and this is the BEST! Whether…

11 minutes minutes

4.87 from 50 votes

About Kristyn

My name is Kristyn and I’m the mom of SIX stinkin’ cute kids and the wife to my smokin’ hot hubby, Lo. My mom’s maiden name is Luna, and I’m one of the many crafty “Lil’ Lunas” in the fam. On this site I like to share all things creative - from recipes to home decor to gifts and home decor ideas. Welcome!

Join the Conversation

Rate and Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Comments:

  1. 5 stars
    I have hard time determining weight or use the knocking method, but I always look for the bee stings and sun spots. I rarely choose a bad melon.

  2. Thank you for the tip on “HOW TO PICK A GOOD WATERMELON.” For me, it’s always been “hit or miss,” but now I believe I’ve “graduated!”

    I use Cook’n software to store all my recipes and would like to add some of yours (with proper credit). Before you say “NO,” feel free to see my cookbooks/recipes to see how I give credit to the cook. They are available (and free to copy) at:
    http://www.dvo.com/cookn/bobf77845

    Will I have your permission to use some in my cookbooks?

See More Comments